Conservative treatment for rotator cuff tears is often recommended as the initial approach due to its effectiveness in managing symptoms and its lower risk of complications compared to surgery. Here is a synthesis of the findings from multiple studies on this topic:
Effectiveness of Conservative Treatment
Pain and Function Improvement: Conservative treatments, including physiotherapy, injections (PRP, collagen, hyaluronic acid, corticosteroids), and pharmacotherapy, have shown significant improvements in pain and functional outcomes for patients with both partial and full-thickness rotator cuff tears1 2 4 9.
Short-term vs. Long-term Outcomes: While conservative treatments yield favorable short-term results in terms of pain reduction and functional recovery, the long-term structural integrity of the rotator cuff remains less certain4 10.
Comparison with Surgical Treatment
Clinical Outcomes: Studies comparing surgical repair to conservative treatment indicate that while surgery may offer slight improvements in pain and function at 6, 12, and 24 months, these differences often do not reach the minimum clinically important difference1 2 8.
Risk and Cost: Conservative treatment is less prone to complications and is more cost-effective than surgical options, making it a preferred initial treatment modality1 5.
Specific Conservative Treatments
Physiotherapy: Exercise therapy, particularly eccentric rehabilitation, has been shown to improve pain and strength in patients with rotator cuff tears3 4 5.
Injections: PRP, collagen, hyaluronic acid, and corticosteroid injections have demonstrated significant improvements in pain and functional scores, although their long-term benefits require further investigation4.
Recommendations
Initial Treatment: Given the limited evidence favoring surgery over conservative treatment, a conservative approach is generally advocated as the first line of treatment for rotator cuff tears1 5 9.
Patient Factors: The choice of treatment should consider patient-specific factors such as age, tear size, and overall health. For instance, exercise therapy is often recommended for elderly patients due to poorer surgical outcomes in this group3 7.
Conclusion
Conservative treatment for rotator cuff tears, including physiotherapy and various injections, is effective in managing pain and improving function, particularly in the short term. While surgery may offer slight additional benefits, these are often not clinically significant, and conservative treatment remains the recommended initial approach due to its lower risk and cost. Further high-quality studies are needed to better define the long-term outcomes and optimal conservative treatment protocols.
Title | Authors | Year | Journal |
Surgery or conservative treatment for rotator cuff tear: a meta-analysis | Anssi J Ryösä, K. Laimi, V. Äärimaa, K. Lehtimäki, J. Kukkonen, M. Saltychev | 2017 | Disability and Rehabilitation |
Rotator cuff repair versus nonoperative treatment: a systematic review with meta-analysis. | F. Brindisino, M. Salomon, S. Giagio, Chiara Pastore, T. Innocenti | 2021 | Journal of shoulder and elbow srgry |
Exercise therapy for the conservative management of full thickness tears of the rotator cuff: a systematic review | R. Ainsworth, Jeremy S. Lewis | 2007 | British Journal of Sports Medicine |
Conservative Management of Partial Thickness Rotator Cuff Tears: A Systematic Review | U. Longo, Alberto Lalli, Giovanna Medina, Nicola Maffulli | 2023 | Sports Medicine and Arthroscopy |
Conservative treatment and rotator cuff tear progression. | U. Longo, F. Franceschi, A. Berton, N. Maffulli, Vincenzo Droena | 2012 | Medicine and sport science |
Multiple Treatment Comparisons for Large and Massive Rotator Cuff Tears: A Network Meta-analysis | C. Maillot, Alice Martellotto, H. Demezon, Édouard Harly, J. Le Huec | 2019 | Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine |
Consensus Statement on the Treatment of Massive Irreparable Rotator Cuff Tears - A Delphi Approach by the Neer Circle of the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons. | P. St. Pierre, P. Millett, J. Abboud, F. Cordasco, D. Cuff, D. Dines, G. Dornan, X. Duralde, L. Galatz, C. Jobin, J. Kuhn, W. Levine, Jonathan C. Levy, M. Mighell, M. Provencher, Dylan R. Rakowski, J. Tibone, J. Tokish | 2021 | Journal of shoulder and elbow srgry |
Comparing surgical repair with conservative treatment for degenerative rotator cuff tears: a randomized controlled trial. | F. L. Lambers Heerspink, J. van Raay, R. Koorevaar, Pepijn J M van Eerden, R. Westerbeek, E. van ’t Riet, I. van den Akker-Scheek, R. Diercks | 2015 | Journal of shoulder and elbow srgry |
Role And Outcomes of Conservative Treatment in Management of Rotator Cuff Tears: A Systematic Review of Randomised Controlled Trials | Andrew Arjun Sayampanathan, M. Tan, D. Lie | 2021 | Asian Journal of Arthroscopy |
Clinical results of conservative management in patients with full-thickness rotator cuff tear: a meta-analysis | Masaki Karasuyama, M. Gotoh, Keiji Tahara, Junichi Kawakami, Kazuya Madokoro, Takashi Nagamatsu, Takaki Imai, Nobuya Harada, Yumi Kudo, N. Shiba | 2020 | Clinics in Shoulder and Elbow |
Comments